Carl's Place Premium vs Standard Impact Screen in 2026: Still Worth the Upgrade?
Last updated: 2026-04-20
Carl's Place Impact Screen
$389
The most popular golf simulator screen brand in the US. Made in Wisconsin, ships fast. Available from 9x6 feet to 14x10 feet.
View on Brand WebsiteFull ReviewRain or Shine Golf SIG12 Enclosure
$1,299
Complete golf simulator enclosure with screen included. The SIG12 fits a 12-foot wide bay and includes side barriers, top baffle, and impact screen.
View on Brand WebsiteFull ReviewBottom Line
The Premium fabric's projection quality improvement is real and worth it if you are pairing with a 4K projector. With a 1080p projector, the Standard is fine.
Specs Compared
| Feature | Carl's Place Impact Screen | Rain or Shine Golf SIG12 Enclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $389 | $1,299 |
| Our Score | 92/100 (Winner) | 86/100 |
| Rating | 4.8/5 (1,876 reviews) | 4.6/5 (621 reviews) |
Carl's Place Impact Screen: Pros and Cons
Rain or Shine Golf SIG12 Enclosure: Pros and Cons
Which One Should You Buy?
The Premium fabric's projection quality improvement is real and worth it if you are pairing with a 4K projector. With a 1080p projector, the Standard is fine.
If you have budget flexibility, our detailed reviews cover both products in depth. The right choice often comes down to how you plan to use the monitor.
Other Comparisons You Might Find Useful